St Maarten vs St Barts: Which Island Is Better to Visit?

Trying to decide between St Maarten vs St Barts for your next Caribbean getaway? These two neighboring islands offer stunning beaches, vibrant culture, and luxury experiences — but they cater to very different travel styles.

Having visited both islands multiple times, I’ve put together this in-depth comparison to help you decide which destination is the best fit for your next trip. Let’s dive in! 🌴✈️

Click the Play button below to listen to our podcast:

1. Island Size & Accessibility

St. Maarten’s Accessibility

St. Maarten is 37 square miles and is divided into two territories: the Dutch side (Sint Maarten) and the French side (Saint-Martin). It has the well-connected Princess Juliana International Airport (SXM), which offers direct flights from major cities in North America and Europe. St. Maarten also serves as the main hub for reaching St. Barts and nearby islands like Anguilla and Saba.

💡 Personal Insight: I loved how easy it was to hop from St. Maarten to nearby islands. Plus, landing at SXM and watching planes fly over Maho Beach is an unforgettable experience.

St. Barts’ Accessibility

St. Barts (officially Saint Barthélemy) is a smaller, exclusive French island at only 9 square miles. There’s no direct international airport, so most visitors arrive via a short 15-minute flight from St. Maarten or by ferry. The small Gustaf III Airport (SBH) is famous for its dramatic runway, which is a thrill in itself.

💡 Personal Insight: The flight into St. Barts is one of the most scenic (and heart-racing) experiences I’ve ever had. The tiny plane and steep descent make it feel like an adventure before you even land.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (Easier access with direct international flights)

2. Beaches & Water Activities

St. Maarten’s Beaches

St. Maarten offers a wide variety of beaches, from the iconic Maho Beach, famous for plane spotting, to the relaxing Mullet Bay Beach and the lively, clothing-optional Orient Bay Beach. It’s perfect for swimming, snorkeling, and jet skiing.

💡 First-Hand Experience: Floating in the calm waters of Mullet Bay with a rum punch in hand was pure bliss.

St. Barts’ Beaches

St. Barts is known for its pristine, white-sand beaches with crystal-clear waters. St. Jean Beach is great for people-watching and watersports, while Gouverneur Beach and Saline Beach are more secluded and peaceful. The snorkeling and sailing experiences here are top-notch.

💡 Personal Insight: Snorkeling at Colombier Beach felt like discovering a secret paradise. The water was unbelievably clear, and there were barely any crowds.

🏆 Winner: St. Barts (More secluded, luxury beaches)

3. Nightlife & Entertainment

St. Maarten’s Nightlife

St. Maarten is known for its vibrant nightlife and casino scene, especially in Maho Village, where you’ll find beach bars, nightclubs, and live music venues. Popular spots include Sunset Beach Bar, Mimosa Sky Lounge Rooftop Lounge, and Lotus Nightclub.

💡 First-Hand Experience: Dancing under the stars at Sky Beach with ocean views was unforgettable.

St. Barts’ Nightlife

St. Barts offers a more upscale and exclusive nightlife scene, with trendy beach clubs like Nikki Beach, fine dining spots, and elegant cocktail bars. The vibe is sophisticated and luxurious, often attracting celebrities and jet-setters.

💡 Personal Insight: Sipping champagne at Bonito Restaurant while watching the sunset over Gustavia harbor felt like something out of a movie.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (More variety and late-night options)

4. Resorts & Accommodations

St. Maarten’s Resorts

St. Maarten offers a wide range of accommodations to suit all types of travelers. For those seeking a more budget-friendly stay, there are plenty of charming boutique hotels and mid-range properties. If you’re looking for an all-inclusive experience, resorts like Sonesta Ocean Point and Divi Little Bay Beach Resort offer beachfront access and numerous amenities, perfect for families or couples. The island also has numerous vacation rentals, from cozy condos to larger villas, making it easy to find something that fits your style and budget.

St. Barts’ Resorts

St. Barts is renowned for its luxury villas and five-star resorts, which cater to those seeking ultimate privacy and exclusivity. Iconic properties like Eden Rock, perched on a hill overlooking St. Jean Bay, and Le Barthélemy Hotel & Spa, with its private beach and world-class service, are just the beginning. Many of the island’s accommodations include private villas with pools, personal chefs, and bespoke services, ensuring a high-end, intimate experience for visitors. St. Barts’ boutique hotels also offer a sleek, modern design that complements the island’s chic atmosphere.

🏆 Winner: St. Barts (For luxury stays), St. Maarten (For budget-friendly options)

5. Cost & Budget Considerations

St. Maarten’s Costs

St. Maarten is widely regarded as more affordable compared to many Caribbean destinations, especially for travelers on a budget. Dining options range from casual beachside eateries to more upscale restaurants, with many offering excellent value for money. Accommodations cater to all budgets, from charming guesthouses and boutique hotels to all-inclusive resorts that include meals and activities. Additionally, the island’s duty-free shopping is a major draw, where visitors can score great deals on jewelry, electronics, and designer goods without the hefty price tags found elsewhere in the Caribbean. Overall, St. Maarten offers a diverse selection of budget-friendly options for those looking to enjoy a Caribbean vacation without breaking the bank.

St. Barts’ Costs

St. Barts is notorious for its high-end lifestyle, with luxury resorts, fine dining, and exclusive experiences that come at a premium. Accommodations in St. Barts are typically pricey, with most options falling into the luxury category, whether it’s a private villa with a pool or a five-star boutique hotel. Dining in St. Barts tends to lean towards gourmet, with upscale restaurants and celebrity-chef-run eateries commanding high prices. While you can find some more affordable options, the island’s overall cost reflects its reputation as a haven for the rich and famous.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (More budget-friendly)

6. Weather & Climate

Both St. Maarten and St. Barts enjoy warm, tropical weather year-round, making them ideal destinations for sun-seekers. However, there are subtle differences between the two islands in terms of climate.

St. Maarten’s Weather

St. Maarten experiences a tropical climate with hot, sunny days and a wetter season from June to November, particularly during the hurricane season. While the island still sees pleasant weather during the off-season, there is a higher chance of rain, especially in the summer months. This is the time when crowds tend to thin out, but there’s always a risk of a sudden downpour. If you’re visiting during hurricane season, it’s a good idea to keep an eye on the weather forecast.

St. Barts’ Weather

St. Barts, located farther south, enjoys a slightly drier climate compared to St. Maarten, making it a more consistent destination year-round. The island tends to experience less rainfall overall, and its breezy conditions make the heat more bearable. Even during the off-season, St. Barts remains more comfortable, with fewer chances of rainfall disrupting your beach time or outdoor adventures. The dry weather combined with a more secluded atmosphere adds to its appeal for those seeking uninterrupted sunshine.

🏆 Winner: St. Barts (More consistent weather)

7. Outdoor Adventures & Activities

St. Maarten’s Adventures

St. Maarten is an adventure lover’s paradise, offering a wide array of activities for those seeking excitement and thrills. For adrenaline junkies, the island has zip-lining at Loterie Farm, where you can soar through the treetops and enjoy panoramic views of the lush landscape. ATV tours allow you to explore rugged terrains and hidden spots that most tourists never see. Additionally, boat trips to nearby islands like Anguilla offer opportunities for snorkeling, relaxing on pristine beaches, and enjoying the warm Caribbean waters. Whether you’re looking to try something new or just enjoy a fun outdoor experience, St. Maarten provides plenty of action-packed options.

St. Barts’ Activities

While St. Barts may not have the same range of heart-pounding activities, it excels in offering exclusive, nature-based experiences. The island is renowned for its world-class snorkeling and sailing opportunities, with crystal-clear waters perfect for exploring coral reefs and marine life. For those who enjoy hiking, the island features scenic trails that lead to secluded beaches like Colombier, where you can soak in the serene atmosphere away from the crowds. The island also offers luxury yacht charters, where you can sail around the island or even to neighboring locations in complete privacy and style.

🏆 Winner: St. Barts (More exclusive, nature-based experiences)

8. Shopping & Local Markets

St. Maarten’s Shopping

St. Maarten is a shopper’s paradise, particularly for those looking to score great deals on luxury goods. The island is famous for its duty-free shopping, with Front Street in Philipsburg offering a wide variety of stores where you can purchase high-end jewelry, watches, and electronics at significantly lower prices. From well-known luxury brands to local souvenirs, there’s something for everyone. If you’re seeking a bargain, this is the place to find designer items without the premium price tag. The shopping scene is diverse, offering plenty of budget-friendly options alongside the luxury items.

St. Barts’ Shopping

St. Barts offers a more exclusive shopping experience with high-end French boutiques lining the streets of Gustavia, the island’s capital. Here, you’ll find a selection of designer stores like Hermès, Louis Vuitton, and Chanel, where you can indulge in luxury shopping. While St. Barts is perfect for those seeking top-tier fashion and accessories, it does come with a higher price point. The shopping scene here is chic and tailored to an upscale clientele looking for something special, making it a prime destination for luxury shoppers.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (More affordable shopping options)

9. Final Verdict: Which Island Should You Visit?

✅ Choose St. Maarten if you want:

• Vibrant nightlife and casinos
• Affordable accommodations and dining
• Easy access to nearby islands
• Duty-free shopping

✅ Choose St. Barts if you want:

• Luxury resorts and private villas
• Exclusive, secluded beaches
• Upscale dining and French culture
• A more quiet, sophisticated atmosphere

10. How This Was Researched

This guide is based on my personal travel experiences to both St. Maarten and St. Barts, along with insights from local residents and fellow travelers. I also fact-checked with official tourism websites and travel forums to ensure accuracy and provide the most helpful information for your trip.

No matter which island you choose, you’re in for an unforgettable Caribbean experience! 🌴