St Maarten vs St Lucia (Which Island Is Better For You?)

St Maarten vs St Lucia. Which island should you visit on your next vacation? St. Maarten and St. Lucia are two beautiful islands in the Caribbean, but they have some key differences that may make one more attractive to you than the other. We will explore the culture, natural beauty, food, and activities on each island to help you decide which is best for your vacation! 

St Maarten vs St Lucia

When it comes to deciding where to go on vacation, there are many factors to consider. St. Maarten and St. lucia are two of the most popular travel destinations. Both have their own unique appeal, but which one is right for you? Here is a comparison of the two islands to help you decide.

St. Maarten is a Dutch island that is well known for its gorgeous beaches and casinos. The island is small, making it easy to explore everything it has to offer. There are plenty of activities available, such as diving, sailing, and golfing. The nightlife is also lively, with casinos and bars open until the early hours of the morning.

St. Lucia is a beautiful Caribbean island that is known for its stunning scenery and friendly people. The island has a wide variety of activities available, from hiking and zip lining to swimming with dolphins.

When it comes to deciding where to go on vacation, there are a lot of factors to consider. Do you want to relax on the beach? Or maybe go shopping? How about the cost? And what about the weather? Some pros and cons are listed here to help you make your decision easier.

1. Size: St. Maarten is the smaller of the two islands, measuring just 37 square miles. But that doesn’t mean it is lacking in things to do – in fact, there’s plenty of excitement to be had here. The island is home to both a Dutch and French side, each with its own unique flavor.

You can explore lively towns filled with casinos and restaurants, or relax on stunning beaches surrounded by crystal clear water. St. Lucia, on the other hand, is much bigger – measuring over 238.2 square miles. 

2. Beaches: St. Maarten is known for its beautiful beaches, which offer both tranquility and excitement, depending on what you’re looking for.

The weather is usually sunny and warm, although hurricane season can be a bit unpredictable. However, if you’re looking for something more secluded and relaxed, St. Lucia is the better option.

With fewer tourists, the beaches here feel more private and pristine. St. Lucia offers stunning scenery and some of the best beaches in the world, making it a popular destination for vacationers.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

3. Nightlife:​​​​​​​ If you want a more laid-back, quiet vacation, then St. Lucia may be a better choice – it is less developed than St. Maarten and has a slower pace of life. However, if you’re looking for more excitement and a lively party atmosphere nightlife, then St. Maarten is probably the better destination. It has a larger number of restaurants and bars, as well as dozens of casinos and other entertainment options.​​​​​​​

4. Activities: Both destinations offer plenty of activities for tourists to enjoy, including swimming, sunbathing, snorkeling, sailing, and hiking. If you’re interested in nature and outdoor activities, go with St. Lucia.

The island has lush rain forests, active volcanoes, and stunning waterfalls. St. Maarten is mostly flat and built up, so there’s not much natural scenery to be found there.

But, if you’re looking for an action-packed vacation, then St. Maarten is definitely the better choice. With its lively casinos, world-class restaurants, and stunning beaches, there’s something for everyone on this island.

5. Cost: Both islands are also relatively affordable compared to other Caribbean destinations. St. Maarten is a bit more expensive than St. Lucia, with food and drinks costing about 10-20% more on average.

However, St. Maarten does have a wider range of luxury resorts and its airport is much larger, making it a popular choice for those looking for a more upscale experience.

St. Lucia is much more affordable, with most restaurants charging around $10-$15 for a meal. There are also many beaches that are free to visit, such as Anse Chastanet Beach and Pigeon Island National Park.

6. Weather: Both the Dutch and French islands of St. Maarten and british island St. Lucia are known for their beautiful beaches, turquoise waters, and lovely year-round weather. But which one is better for a vacation?

St. Maarten is home to both the Dutch and French cultures, so you can enjoy the best of both worlds on this island. The Dutch side is more developed, with casinos, nightlife, and shopping, while the French side is more laid-back with charming villages and lovely beaches.

St. Lucia is a bit more rugged than St. Maarten, with rain forests and volcanic peaks, but it also has some lovely white-sand beaches. The weather on both islands is great year-round, with temperatures in the 70s to low 80s F (23 to 28 C) and usually little rainfall.

7. Shopping: When it comes to shopping, there are pros and cons to each island. St Maarten is known for its high-end shopping, with brands like Cartier and Louis Vuitton.

However, St Lucia has a more diverse range of stores, with something for everyone. If you’re looking for designer clothes, shoes and accessories, then St Maarten is the place to go. But if you’re looking for souvenirs, local art or bargains, then St Lucia is the better option. 

If you’re looking for a lively beach town with plenty of shopping and restaurants, St. Maarten is the better choice. The island has a Dutch influence, so you can expect narrow streets and colorful buildings. 

8. History: ​​​​​​​One of the biggest differences between the two islands is their history. St. Maarten was colonized by the Dutch in 1632, while St. Lucia was first settled by the French in 1650 before being taken over by the British in 1814. This influence is still seen today, with French-speaking areas on St. Lucia and Dutch-speaking areas on St. Maarten.

9. Crime: St. Lucia is known for its low crime rate and peaceful atmosphere, making it a popular destination for families and solo travelers alike. St. Maarten, while also lovely, is home to a higher crime rate, making it less desirable for some visitors.

Which island should be your vacation destination next? If safety is your top priority, then St. Lucia is the clear choice. However, if you’re looking for something a little more lively and exciting, St. Maarten may be the better option.

10: Location: St. Maarten is located in the northeastern corner of the Caribbean Sea, just below Puerto Rico. St. Lucia is located about halfway down the eastern side of the Caribbean, just northwest of Barbados.

Is St. Martin or St Lucia better?

Both Saint Martin and Saint Lucia are beautiful Caribbean islands, but which one is the best?  It all depends on what you are looking for. Saint Martin is a tiny island with a population of just over 80,000 people.

It is known for its luxurious resorts and stunning beaches. The island has a mix of French and Dutch cultures, so you can enjoy both European and Caribbean cuisine. Saint Lucia is larger than Saint Martin, with a population of 185,000 people.

It is known for its rainforests and volcanic peaks. The coastline also features an abundance of amazing beaches. The island has a more traditional Caribbean vibe, with lots of reggae music and delicious food options.

Is St Lucia close to St Maarten?

The island of St. Lucia is located just north of the island of St. Maarten. Both islands are in the eastern Caribbean Sea and are part of the Lesser Antilles. The two islands are about 318.26 miles (512.18 kilometers) apart, and it takes about three hours to fly between them.

How far is St Lucia from St Maarten?

The distance between the two islands is about 318 miles. While this may seem like a lot, it’s a relatively short trip when you take into account the open waters that separate them. The trip usually takes around two hours, although wind and weather conditions can affect how long it takes to make the crossing. 

Those looking to visit both islands on the same trip will find that there are plenty of options for doing so. Many cruise lines offer trips that stop in both St Lucia and St Maarten, and there are also several airlines that fly between the two airports.

If you’re looking to explore each island on its own, however, there are plenty of options for doing so as well. St Lucia is known for its lush rain forests and white sand beaches, while St Maarten is home to busy towns and world-famous casinos.

Is St Lucia the most beautiful island?

There are so many beautiful islands in the world that it is hard to compare them all. However, if you ask someone who has been to St Lucia, they will probably say that it is one of the most beautiful places they have ever been. One of the things that makes St Lucia so special is its natural beauty.

The island is covered in lush rain forests and surrounded by stunning beaches. There are also several volcanoes on the island, including the iconic Mount Gimie.

St Lucia is also home to some of the most amazing wildlife in the world, including humpback whales and green monkeys. Another thing that makes St Lucia stand out from other islands is its culture.

Related Post:


  • Karin K

    Meet Karin, the passionate author and founder of My love affair with St. Maarten began in 1994 during a memorable trip. The island's allure was so captivating that I decided to make it my permanent home. Since then, I've been committed to sharing the beauty and wonders of St. Maarten through my adventures and insights. Join me on this incredible journey!