St Maarten vs St Thomas: Which One Should You Visit?

Some of the links in this blog may result in earning a commission if you make a purchase. However, I only recommend products or services based on my personal experience and honest opinion.

Trying to decide between St Maarten vs St Thomas for your next Caribbean getaway? Both islands offer breathtaking beaches, lively nightlife, and a mix of adventure and relaxation. But which one is the best fit for your travel style?

I’ve explored both destinations firsthand and gathered insights from other travelers to create this in-depth comparison. Whether you’re looking for luxury, adventure, or affordability, this guide will help you choose the perfect island. Let’s dive in!

Click the Play button below to listen to our podcast:

Island Size & Accessibility

When it comes to size, St. Thomas is slightly smaller, covering 32 square miles, while St. Maarten is 37 square miles. However, the real difference lies in accessibility and layout. St. Maarten is unique in that it is split between two nations: the Dutch side (Sint Maarten) and the French side (Saint-Martin). This means you can experience two different cultures on one island, something St. Thomas doesn’t offer.

St. Maarten is more cosmopolitan, with Princess Juliana International Airport (SXM) handling more international flights. Tourists can easily access this bustling island from Europe, North America, and other parts of the Caribbean. On the flip side, St. Thomas mainly caters to U.S. travelers, and Cyril E. King Airport (STT) offers fewer international flights but a more relaxed travel experience for American visitors. St. Thomas’s accessibility is also improved by its status as part of the U.S. Virgin Islands, meaning U.S. citizens don’t need a passport for travel, a significant bonus for those looking for a hassle-free getaway.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (Unique two-nation experience and better international flight options)

A stunning aerial view of St. Maarten's beautiful coastline

Beaches & Water Activities

If your dream vacation revolves around stunning beaches and water adventures, both islands have incredible options, but they cater to different tastes. St. Maarten offers a mix of lively and secluded beaches, while St. Thomas is all about crystal-clear waters and snorkeling-friendly bays.

In St. Maarten, you’ll find Maho Beach, a must-see where planes land right above you, creating an adrenaline-pumping experience. Orient Bay Beach offers thrilling water sports, from jet skiing to parasailing, while Mullet Bay Beach is ideal for those seeking tranquility on soft, golden sands. If you’re a snorkeling enthusiast, Creole Rock near Grand Case offers a great underwater adventure.

St. Thomas boasts some of the Caribbean’s most scenic beaches. Magens Bay Beach is often regarded as one of the most beautiful beaches in the world, with its calm waters perfect for a swim or a relaxing day by the shore. For those who love snorkeling, Coki Beach is unmatched, with vibrant coral reefs and abundant marine life. Divers will find their paradise at Cow and Calf Rocks, where crystal-clear waters unveil the wonders of the underwater world.

💡 Personal Insight: I had a blast snorkeling at Coki Beach in St. Thomas, where I swam with an array of tropical fish. While St. Maarten’s beaches offered excitement, St. Thomas stole my heart with its serene beauty and world-class snorkeling.

🏆 Winner: St. Thomas (Better for crystal-clear waters, snorkeling, and diving)


Nightlife & Entertainment

If nightlife is a top priority, St. Maarten takes the crown. The island is known for its electrifying beach parties, casinos, and late-night clubs, particularly in the Maho Village area, where you’ll find everything from live music to international DJs.

St. Thomas has a more laid-back nightlife scene, perfect for those looking to enjoy a quieter evening. Beachfront bars like Duffy’s Love Shack and Moe’s Fresh Market offer refreshing cocktails and great vibes. While there are a few dance clubs in St. Thomas, they don’t compare to the non-stop energy of St. Maarten‘s entertainment scene, where you can easily find a lively spot to dance the night away.

💡 First-Hand Experience: I spent an unforgettable night at one of St. Maarten’s casinos and danced until the early hours in Maho Village. By contrast, St. Thomas had more intimate, mellow nights with reggae tunes and beachfront dinners.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (More options for nightlife and entertainment)


Resorts & Accommodations

St. Thomas leans toward high-end resorts and beachfront hotels, while St. Maarten offers a mix of luxury, boutique, and budget-friendly stays.

St. Thomas offers plush accommodations like the Ritz-Carlton and Bolongo Bay Beach Resort, where you can enjoy the epitome of relaxation, fine dining, and exceptional service. These luxurious resorts are ideal for honeymooners or anyone looking for that top-tier vacation experience. St. Thomas also offers smaller boutique hotels and vacation rentals that cater to those seeking a more private, cozy getaway.

In St. Maarten, you have options to match every budget. Sonesta Ocean Point Resort is an upscale all-inclusive resort that promises a luxurious experience, while the La Samanna, A Belmond Hotel, delivers European elegance with a Caribbean twist. Mary’s Boon Beach Resort is a great option for travelers looking for charm without the hefty price tag, offering affordable beachfront rooms.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (More variety in accommodations)


Cost & Budget Considerations

St. Maarten is generally more budget-friendly than St. Thomas when it comes to accommodations, dining, and activities. Meals in Grand Case (St. Maarten’s French side) offer gourmet French cuisine at reasonable prices, while beachside “lolos” serve up delicious grilled seafood for under $15. The island has plenty of affordable eateries and activities for those on a tighter budget, making it an attractive destination for travelers seeking value without sacrificing quality.

St. Thomas, being part of the U.S., tends to have higher prices, particularly when it comes to food, drinks, and excursions. On the upside, it offers duty-free shopping, so you can snag high-end items like jewelry and luxury watches at discounted rates. However, St. Thomas does have higher hotel and rental car costs compared to St. Maarten, which could impact those on a stricter budget. Fortunately, you can still find mid-range accommodations and casual dining options if you’re mindful of your spending.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (Better for budget-conscious travelers)


Weather & Climate

Both islands have warm, tropical weather year-round, but St. Maarten gets slightly more rain and occasional hurricanes due to its location. St. Thomas, being further east in the Caribbean, tends to have a more stable climate, with fewer rainy days. However, the overall tropical climate of both islands means you can expect warm temperatures and beautiful sunny days.

St. Maarten has an average temperature of around 80°F, but during the hurricane season (June–November), there is a higher chance of rainfall. St. Thomas, on the other hand, is favored by travelers seeking more consistent sunny weather, with less rainfall during the summer months. If you’re planning to travel during the off-season, St. Thomas might be a better choice for more predictable conditions.

💡 Weather Tip: If traveling during hurricane season (June–November), St. Thomas has a slightly lower risk of storms.

🏆 Winner: St. Thomas (More consistent sunny weather)

Aerial view of St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands.
St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands Photo by Kellie Klumb on Unsplash

Outdoor Adventures & Activities

If you’re into hiking, zip-lining, and adventure sports, St. Maarten wins. The Flying Dutchman is the steepest zip-line in the world, offering an exhilarating experience, while hiking Pic Paradis lets you reach the island’s highest peak, offering panoramic views of the surroundings.

St. Thomas excels in its boating and sailing excursions, with trips to nearby St. John and the British Virgin Islands (BVI) making it a great option for those seeking a seafaring adventure. Honeymoon Beach on Water Island is another hidden gem, offering a peaceful escape from the more crowded tourist spots.

🏆 Winner: St. Maarten (More adventure-based activities)


Shopping & Local Markets

Both islands offer duty-free shopping, but St. Thomas has the edge with better deals on luxury goods. Main Street in Charlotte Amalie is packed with jewelry stores, designer brands, and souvenirs.

St. Maarten has Front Street in Philipsburg, where you can find local boutiques and duty-free deals. However, its shopping options are smaller compared to St. Thomas, where you’ll find a broader range of luxury and designer goods, perfect for those looking to indulge in high-end retail therapy.

🏆 Winner: St. Thomas (Better for duty-free shopping)


Final Verdict: Which Island Should You Visit?

✅ Choose St. Maarten if you want:

  • Exciting nightlife and casinos
  • A mix of Dutch and French culture
  • Budget-friendly dining and hotels
  • Thrilling adventure activities

✅ Choose St. Thomas if you want:

  • Crystal-clear snorkeling beaches
  • Luxury resorts and high-end shopping
  • Consistent sunny weather
  • Easy U.S. travel with no passport required

How This Was Researched

This comparison is based on my own travel experiences, insights from locals, and feedback from fellow travelers. I’ve visited both islands multiple times, gathering first-hand knowledge and conducting thorough research on hotel and flight prices. By speaking with locals and reviewing tourism data, I’ve compiled a well-rounded analysis to help you make the best choice for your Caribbean getaway.

So, which island is calling your name?

Related Post:

Author

  • Karin K in SXM.

    Meet Karin, the passionate author and founder of StMaartenAdventure.com. My love affair with St. Maarten began in 1994 during a memorable trip. The island's allure was so captivating that I decided to make it my permanent home. Since then, I've been committed to sharing the beauty and wonders of St. Maarten through my adventures and insights. Join me on this incredible journey!

    View all posts