St Maarten vs Dominican Republic: Which is the Most Fun?

When it comes to vacation destinations, the Caribbean islands are hard to beat. With crystal-clear water, white-sand beaches, and lush tropical vegetation, they offer something for everyone.

Two of the most popular destinations in the region are St. Maarten and the Dominican Republic. So which one should you choose?

St Maarten vs Dominican Republic Comparison

When it comes to Caribbean vacations, there are two primary destinations that people think of: St. Maarten and the Dominican Republic. Both countries offer incredible beaches and plenty of activities to keep you busy, but there are some key differences that you should consider before making your decision.

1. Size: The Dominican Republic is a larger country, which means that you have more options when it comes to beaches and activities. There are also more resorts and all-inclusive hotels available, making it a great option for those who want to relax without having to worry about anything.

St. Maarten is a smaller island, which means that the beaches are more crowded during peak season. However, the island offers a wide variety of restaurants and activities, so there is something for everyone. Overall, the Dominican Republic is a great option if you want plenty of options and room to explore.

2. Beaches: The Dominican Republic is known for its more secluded beaches, while St Maarten is known for its lively and vibrant atmosphere. If you’re looking for a quiet and relaxing beach vacation, then the Dominican Republic is probably a better choice. But if you’re looking for a more exciting and party-friendly atmosphere, then St Maarten is definitely the better option.

Both destinations offer stunningly beautiful beaches, so it really comes down to your personal preference. In my opinion, both destinations are worth exploring and offer something unique and special.​​​​​​​

Maho Beach, St. Maarten
Image by kendallpools from Pixabay

3. Nightlife: If nightlife is your thing, St. Maarten is definitely the place to be. The island has a thriving club scene, with something for everyone, no matter what your taste in music may be.

If drinking and dancing until the early hours of the morning isn’t your idea of a good time, you might want to consider the Dominican Republic instead – it’s much more laid-back and doesn’t have quite as many late-night options.

4. Activities: St Maarten is a Dutch territory that is known for its beautiful beaches, crystal-clear waters, and lively nightlife scene. The island is also home to a number of casinos, making it a popular destination for gambling enthusiasts. The Dominican Republic is a country located on the eastern side of the Caribbean Sea.

It offers visitors miles of white sand beaches, lush rainforests, and plenty of opportunities for adventure sports such as zip lining and horseback riding. When it comes to activities, Dominican Republic definitely has the edge over the St Maarten.

5. Cost: The first major difference is cost. The Dominican Republic is much more affordable than St. Martin/St. Maarten. For example, a meal at an inexpensive restaurant in the Dominican Republic will cost around $5-10, while in St. Maarten it will be closer to $15-20.

Accommodations are also less expensive in the Dominican Republic; you can find a nice hotel room for under $100 per night, while similar accommodations in St.​​​​​​​ Maarten is around $250 per night.

6. Weather: Both islands have tropical climates, with average temperatures ranging from 75-85 degrees Fahrenheit. However, St Maarten tends to be a bit wetter, with more rainfall than the Dominican Republic.

7. Shopping: When it comes to shopping, the two countries are quite different. In St. Maarten, there are many duty-free shops, as well as local vendors selling a variety of items. The typical souvenirs you’ll find in St. Maarten include jewelry, t-shirts, and postcards.

In the Dominican Republic, you’ll find a mix of duty-free shops and local vendors. However, the selection of items is not as diverse as in St. Maarten. If you’re looking for high-end brands or unique souvenirs, St. Maarten is your best bet.

8. Crime: Both islands have their pros and cons when it comes to crime and tourist safety. St. Maarten is known for being a relatively safe destination, with low levels of crime. However, there have been cases of petty theft and purse-snatching on the island in recent years.

The Dominican Republic is notorious for its high levels of crime, including murder, robbery and assault. In particular, tourists are often targeted in violent crimes such as muggings and scams.

9. Location: St Maarten is located in the northeast Caribbean, while the Dominican Republic is located in the eastern Caribbean. So if you’re looking for something more off the beaten path, then the Dominican Republic may be a better choice.

10. Towns and villages: St Maarten is known for its towns and villages. Philipsburg, Marigot, and Grand Case are all charming places to wander around, with lots of restaurants and shops to explore.

The beaches here are also some of the best in the Caribbean, with crystal-clear water and white sand. The Dominican Republic is a bit more varied in terms of landscape.

You can find everything from mountains to rainforest to beaches here. The towns and villages aren’t quite as charming as those on St Maarten, but they’re still worth exploring.

Is St Maarten or Dominican Republic better?

There are many factors to consider when choosing between Saint Martin and the Dominican Republic as a vacation destination. Both offer beautiful beaches, crystal-clear water, and plenty of activities to keep you busy.

However, the two countries differ in terms of culture, cost, and amenities. Saint Martin is a Dutch territory that offers a European flair with its quaint villages and Dutch architecture.

The country is also home to some of the best shopping in the Caribbean, with both luxury brands and duty-free shops available. Restaurants here cater to all tastes, from French cuisine to local seafood dishes. Accommodations range from luxurious resorts to budget-friendly hotels.

The Dominican Republic is a Spanish-speaking country that offers a more Latin vibe. The beaches here are just as beautiful as those in Saint Martin, but they are often less crowded.

Which part of Dominican Republic is best?

There are many different opinions about which part of the Dominican Republic is best. Some people say that the north is the best, while others say the south is better. There are pros and cons to each side, so it really depends on what you are looking for in a vacation destination.

The north is known for its mountainous terrain and beautiful beaches. It’s a great place to go if you want to enjoy nature and get away from the hustle and bustle of city life. The downside to the north is that it can be quite expensive, especially in the more popular tourist areas.

The south of the country is much more affordable, which makes it a great choice for budget-minded travelers. It’s also home to some of the most beautiful beaches in the Dominican Republic.

What is the richest city in the Dominican Republic?

The richest city in the Dominican Republic is Santo Domingo. The city has a GDP of $239 billion and a per capita GDP of $9,158. The city is home to many wealthy residents and businesses. Santo Domingo is the largest and most populous city in the Dominican Republic. It is the country’s principal city.

Is it better to stay in Punta Cana or Santo Domingo?

There are pros and cons to staying in both Punta Cana and Santo Domingo. Punta Cana is better for those who want a more relaxing vacation, as the beaches are beautiful and there is not much to do besides relax.

Santo Domingo is better for those who want to be more active and see more of the country, as it is located closer to the capital city and has more historical landmarks.

What is the best currency to use in St Maarten?

There are a few things to consider when it comes to choosing the best currency to use in Saint Martin. First, it’s important to know that the island uses both the Euro and the United States Dollar. So, if you’re coming from Europe or another country that uses the Euro, you’ll want to use Euros on the island.

If you’re coming from the United States or another country that uses the U.S. Dollar, you’ll want to use U.S. Dollars on Saint Martin. Another thing to consider is whether or not you’ll be spending time on Saba or Sint Eustatius – two other islands that make up the Kingdom of the Netherlands Antilles.

These two islands use their own unique currency, which is called the Saba Guilder and the Sint Eustatius Guilder, respectively.

Can an American live in St Maarten?

Yes, an American can live in St. Maarten as long as they have the appropriate visa. The island is a popular destination for American expats, and there are many communities of Americans living on the island.

It’s important to note that St. Maarten is a separate country from the United States, and Americans living there will need to follow the laws and regulations of St. Maarten.

What is the safest island in the Caribbean?

Some islands are considered safer than others, due to their low crime rates, lack of natural disasters, and friendly locals.
One such island is Barbados. Barbados is known for its low crime rate and friendly locals.

There have been few reports of violence or crime on the island, making it a safe place for tourists to visit. Barbados is also a relatively small island, which means that it is easier to navigate and there are fewer places for criminals to hide.

Another safe option is Turks and Caicos. Like Barbados, Turks and Caicos has a low crime rate and friendly locals.​​​​​​​

Is Saint Martin safe?

The island has seen its share of crime, and visitors should be aware of the risks. However, with common sense precautions, most travelers find Saint Martin to be a safe and welcoming place. The island’s beaches and tropical climate are a big draw, and tourism is the main industry.

Petty theft does occur, so it’s important to take precautions such as not leaving your belongings unguarded on the beach and making sure your hotel room is secure.

Is Saint Martin tax free?

Yes, Saint Martin is tax-free. There are no property taxes, no personal capital gains taxes, and the duty free port makes it a great place to shop. However, there is a sales tax of 5%. The cost of living is high on Saint Martin, so you’ll want to factor that into your budget.

Related Post:


  • Karin K

    Meet Karin, the passionate author and founder of My love affair with St. Maarten began in 1994 during a memorable trip. The island's allure was so captivating that I decided to make it my permanent home. Since then, I've been committed to sharing the beauty and wonders of St. Maarten through my adventures and insights. Join me on this incredible journey!

    View all posts